Thanks everyone! I was able to pop them out no problem. It was my first time using the Rock Chucker Auto Prime. I believe I figured out the issue. If I didn't have the ram high enough when I pushed the priming arm in the primer would catch on the bottom of the shell holder and flip in the cup before I seated it. I tried the hand priming tool a few times and just didn't like it and the little priming arm that came with the press is not compatible with my fat fingers.

Sent from my SM-G955U using Tapatalk