A couple things of note depending on the alloy you cast your bullets from. Air cooled bullet depending on the alloy will age harden slowly with around 2% Sb ie antimony content I generally let my bullets set about two weeks to obtain final BHN if air cooled, if I water quench the bullets or heat treat I wait around a week before I load and shoot. BHN variations in a given load do make a difference, you can test this by loading up a series of identical loads with bullets cast the same day and shoot a 10 shot group on day one and subsequent 10 shot groups with the same loads a few days apart and see if the groups change.
A few notes on cast bullet air cooled or quenched from the mold and how the curing process will anneal the cast lead bullets using an alloy that responds to water quenching or heat treating. Your results may vary depending on the original alloy used and the as cast BHN and at the time the bullets BHN is tested.
1. If you air cool your bullets when cast then PC them and allow them to air cool again the second time there is no change in the as cast BHN of the bullet.
2. If you air cool your bullets when cast then PC them and quench them right out of the toaster oven they will gain a hardness of about 75% over the as cast BHN.
3. If you quench your bullets out of the mold to begin with then PC them and allow them to air cool they will soften around 50% from the original first quenching BHN.
4. If you quench your bullets out of the mold to begin with then PC them and quench them right out of the toaster oven a second time you only loose around 15% hardness from the first quenching.
As to toaster ovens I like the convection oven as they distribute the heat much better, I also use a reliable over thermometer to make sure my toaster over is set as close to the recommended curing temperature by the powder mfg. as possible. Toaster ovens can vary by as much as +/- 50 degrees from what the dial on the over is set to. I preheated my oven for around 45 min. with the thermometer inside to make sure everything was heat soaked completely and the oven had time to run through several heat cycles before I made the final adjustment to the temperature dial, it's a good idea to check that on occasion as things can change over time.
When coating bullets I crank the toaster oven up and let it run for about 30 min. to heat up while I'm coating and I start timing when the powder begins to flowout. After there done I either air cool or water quench right out of the toaster oven depending on what I'm using the cast bullet for.