Which ever one you decide to get, you'll love the Henrys. I have 6 of them, they shoot great, smooth and reliable. If I had to complain about one thing, it would be the finish. I have a 44 Big Boy Steel, and when I carry it on my Kawasaki Mule in the Gun Rack, after a while it wears the finish on the barrel some. Other than that. Great Rifles.